Tried re-installing the theme. Here is what I did:
1. Activated the WP 2012 default theme instead of Read
2. Deleted Read from the Theme panel
3. Went to Themes –> Add Theme –> Upload
4. Uploaded the theme ZIP file
5. Activated the Theme
Let me know if there’s another way I should have done the re-install. When I re-activated, all our custom CSS was retained, so I didn’t feel like there was a full “fresh” reinstall, if you know what I mean.